What Would YOU Do? Please Advise

Welcome to Discuss Fastpitch

Your FREE Account is waiting to the Best Softball Community on the Web.

Aug 18, 2014
13
0
My husband and I are (were) new 10U rec coaches this season. Had a brand new group of mostly 9 year old's, but not a full team. We hovered around 6 players most of the summer, but got all the way up to ten at one point, and come draft time, we only had our most dedicated 5 actually sign up. Those girls worked very hard all summer.

A week before the draft, we had two scrimmages, and a girl's (we'll call that girl "J") mom brought on two new players that were all about signing on with our team for the season. They played well. Dad 1 was so rude to me he wouldn't bother looking up from his cell phone to speak after the first scrimmage.

Draft day comes around, and an hour before I am to hear from the field director about any new players, J's mom sends me a text and quits the team, saying that her friend was now coaching and she thought it would be a better fit. J got moved to centerfield in the last scrimmage game, because she won't cover her base and won't field a ball. EVER. Mom wants her to play 3rd. (Don't hate me here - I've been under the gun and player poor all summer. Had to put the kid somewhere.) Field director calls, I no longer have a team, because I only have 4 players and there weren't enough in the draft. (I was told there were so many players who came through the draft last fall that they had to find 4 more volunteer coaches. Huh.) We're being merged with another team, who just so happened to have 6 players. The deciding factor was J, or it would have been 5 and 5. The kicker? She went back to the same coach she came from, the one her mom talked crap about to me all summer.

And now we are all one team. And my husband and I are stripped from coaching, because we have no seniority and less players. The other 4 of our dedicated players, including our pitcher, catcher, SS, and our own daughter (3rd), are all devastated. Their parents are angry. They are being replaced by the other coach's picks and will likely be removed to the outfield, benched, or get drastically less mound time or catching time. He has already told them they don't have enough experience so he is bringing in a TB pitcher and catcher. THIS. IS. REC. BALL. His assistant coach? Dad 1, who couldn't be interrupted from his texting long enough to speak to a female, and who also didn't bother to show up to practice.

So, one parent basically ruined my girls' fall season. I was scouted by another coach, set up by an angry parent who thinks her kid is the best on the field, and as new coaches, we don't know enough people in the office. We were told that we had no other choice but to merge. What would you do? I could pull my kid off the team, but then I would let down the rest of the girls. And if DD goes elsewhere, there's another player that will leave also. Then, all of those girls will get split up into other teams. I want these girls to play softball. All of them, and regardless of who coaches. But the unfairness is ridiculous. What would you do? Am I just blowing all this out of proportion, or do I have the right to be angry?
 
Aug 29, 2011
2,584
83
NorCal
I'm confused by the seemingly pre-set teams and draft concept. These 2 seem to be at odds with each other. It sounds like parents get together and form a team that they take to rec. At any rate what you describe sounds like a dysfunctional rec league, at least from what you've laid out.

At this point maybe gut it out for the fall season and work with your DD on the side as much as possible.

Your other options seems to be to try and jump to a TB team looking for players with your core 4, though that will leave the other girls left behind in a lurch.
 

JJsqueeze

Dad, Husband....legend
Jul 5, 2013
5,436
38
safe in an undisclosed location
I'm confused by this as well, all the rec leagues I know of have an eval day and then a draft where players are picked in turn based on rankings. Some special considerations are given to siblings/coaches daughters get to be on dads team, but other than that you get what you get. No way to have 5 girls join and stay together as a team unless they get lucky and get picked via the draft.
 
May 24, 2013
12,461
113
So Cal
I'm confused by this as well, all the rec leagues I know of have an eval day and then a draft where players are picked in turn based on rankings. Some special considerations are given to siblings/coaches daughters get to be on dads team, but other than that you get what you get. No way to have 5 girls join and stay together as a team unless they get lucky and get picked via the draft.

For Spring, this ^ is how our league works, too.

For Fall, however, the Player Agent (one of the Board positions) picks the teams and does his/her best to distribute talent evenly among the teams. For the most part, it works out pretty well.
 
Aug 18, 2014
13
0
In both Spring and Fall leagues, they will accept coaches without teams, teams without coaches, partial teams, or players without teams. There is no specific tryout or player ability determination beforehand.
 
Aug 29, 2011
2,584
83
NorCal
In both Spring and Fall leagues, they will accept coaches without teams, teams without coaches, partial teams, or players without teams. There is no specific tryout or player ability determination beforehand.
That sounds doomed to fail from the start.
You are very likely to wind up with a few teams that come in fully formed with 2 pitchers, 2 catchers and a few stud hitters playing a few Island of Misfit Toy kids who get thrown together.
Sounds like a recipie for disaster designed to cater to the 1 or 2 coaches who want to make their select all-star team their house league rec team w/o moving on to TB.
 

marriard

Not lost - just no idea where I am
Oct 2, 2011
4,319
113
Florida
In both Spring and Fall leagues, they will accept coaches without teams, teams without coaches, partial teams, or players without teams. There is no specific tryout or player ability determination beforehand.

Leave and find new league. You owe nothing to them or anyone else. Take those that want to go with you. If you have to go further, then so be it. League is clearly dysfunctional and nothing is going to change as the people in charge do what favors them and their favorites.

Do what is best for your kid.
 
Jun 7, 2013
984
0
I can totally sympathize with your situation. I've been in many of them myself. You do have an important decision. Do you stay or do you go? Sometimes you put your justifiable anger aside and stay. Other times you go. Do what's best for your DD. And right now, I think, we are talking just fall ball and not your DDs entire playing future. Maybe get thru fall and look around?
 
Aug 18, 2014
13
0
That sounds doomed to fail from the start.
You are very likely to wind up with a few teams that come in fully formed with 2 pitchers, 2 catchers and a few stud hitters playing a few Island of Misfit Toy kids who get thrown together.
Sounds like a recipie for disaster designed to cater to the 1 or 2 coaches who want to make their select all-star team their house league rec team w/o moving on to TB.

That pretty much sums it up. There are teams who shouldn't EVER be playing rec ball in that league. They just do it to beat up on the "Misfit Toy" kids and feel better about themselves because they don't want to expend the time and energy it takes to actually improve lower level players.
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
42,866
Messages
680,338
Members
21,523
Latest member
Brkou812
Top